Pilates is excellent for conditioning the body and strengthening the core. Pilates routines help you create a leaner physique and a more balanced and aligned body. Workouts in the gym are excellent for bulking up, gaining muscle, and burning calories.
Pilates is a low-impact workout that incorporates flexibility, strength, and endurance and is practised on a mat. A whole body workout emphasizes good postural alignment, core strength, and muscular balance.
Pilates was named after its inventor, Joseph Pilates, who created the workout in the 1920s. Gyms provide devices and equipment to encourage you to train your body and muscles in various ways.
Gym workouts can contain a variety of outstanding routines such as aerobic, weight lifting, and bulking up.
The gym offers a plethora of exercises; how you use it and what you do there is entirely up to you. Let’s examine the similarities and differences between these two tasks.
In this Article
Both types of exercise feature exercises that focus on proper postural alignment, core strength and muscle balance.
When you do the exercises, your body is held in perfect alignment with a neutral spine, causing your abdominal muscles to contract and release during each rep.
The combination of weight lifting and cardio workouts are equally effective in increasing fitness level. Both types of exercise also help to improve flexibility, strength and endurance.
They are both great for toning the abdominal muscles, improving posture and reducing back pain. Both also stimulate the heart to achieve a better cardiovascular workout than a traditional cardio workout.
Pilates exercises focus on breathing, muscles and bones that are not used in other activities. It is more about the mind-body connection than focusing on cardiovascular benefits.
The exercises you do at the gym can increase your heart rate, which will help you burn calories, but these exercises also make your joints move beyond their normal range of motion. It could cause injury for some people with weak joints.
Because Pilates is a focused body workout, it will give you a leaner appearance when those muscles are balanced and toned. A gym workout will build and tone muscles all over your body, but it might give you more bulk.
When you’re doing the exercises, typically Pilates is performed on the floor and with your body weight. Workouts at the gym also focus on using your body weight to complete exercises, especially squats, lunges and pushups. Pilates exercise also focuses on core exercise, which is very important for maintaining a healthy, solid and balanced body.
According to the health experts at Drexel University, Pilates exercises help design and maintain a leaner body, improve energy levels and increase muscle tone.
The theory of Pilates is that muscles are not always used precisely the way they're supposed to be used in everyday life, so you don't necessarily use them all the time.
However, doing the exercises helps you achieve a more balanced, toned, and healthy body. The time you spend will determine the benefits of each workout
Pilates body vs gym body: Which one is better?
We pitted them against each other in ten categories to see who came out on top.
Best for Fat Loss:
Pilates may engage your entire body and will likely burn more calories faster than cardio at the gym, especially when using Pilates equipment, which can enhance the cardio and fitness element, making Pilates a winner when it comes to fat loss.
Best at Building Muscle:
Lifting weights will build up your muscles. However, Pilates will help you grow muscle without bulking up.
When it comes to muscle building, one method may be better than the other, depending on the intensity of the workout and the appearance you desire. However, we’ll stick with the gym for the sake of this post.
Best at Strengthening Core:
Pilates and gym activities effectively strengthen the core. On the other hand, Pilates focuses primarily on core strength, and the intensity delivers a more significant benefit, making it the victor in this category.
Burned the most calories in the shortest amount of time:
This may or may not be the case, depending on the type of workouts you undertake at the gym. Running for 30 minutes will burn approximately 300 calories.
You can burn 180 calories in a 30-minute Pilates class, and you can burn an additional 90 calories every 15 minutes if you continue. The gym comes out on top here.
Best Full Body Workout:
Pilates is the best full-body workout since it combines a variety of equipment and routines to tone muscles, strengthen the core, burn calories, and more.
In Pilates, you work both sides of your body simultaneously, which is an added benefit overworking each muscle independently at the gym. In this case, Pilates comes out on top.
Best workout for Busy People:
Gyms require a commute, which can add time to your day. Pilates is the most excellent choice for busy people because it can be done in a class or at home.
Best for back pain:
Pilates movements focus on straightening the spine and strengthening the upper and lower back, joints, and core, all of which are important for pain relief. Muscle strain and damage are common side effects of gym training. Pilates is the clear winner in this contest.
Best for Stress Relief:
Both Pilates and the gym can raise your heart rate and help you relax. We would suggest Pilates as a stress reliever, but it is a matter of personal preference.
Best for interval training:
Interval training is a great way to burn calories, increase cardiovascular fitness and improve performance during specific exercises.
While there is a large amount of research supporting this method, you also need to be aware that it can increase your risk of injury if you are not adequately trained.
Best for amateur bodybuilders:
The gym would likely help you build muscle more efficiently than Pilates, but Pilates will help you achieve a leaner, more toned look to your physique.
Best for Women:
The greater capacity to hold and control your weight makes women more desirable. They won’t bulk up like a man lifting weights if they use essential gym equipment.
Best for the elderly:
Our bodies change as we age, impairing the ability to keep up with a strenuous workout regimen. Pilates is very adaptive to changing muscle mass and ranges of motion for sensitive joints and is safe for people over the age of 65, whereas gym workouts are not as effective in this category.
In conclusion, Pilates is the winner simply because it gives you more bang for your buck. While the gym and Pilates both provide a leaner appearance and excellent benefits, you will be getting more if you choose Pilates.
Pilates is the best choice for busy people, the elderly, fat loss, core strength, stress relief, and interval training compared to the gym.
The gym would benefit those who build muscle efficiently or lose weight by toning their muscles using cardio.
So, while both Pilates and the gym offer great results, if you want a more extensive range of benefits, Pilates is your best bet.